Harry Potter Video Game Evolution: From Early Titles to Hogwarts Legacy and Future Games

by Falagar / Editorials, Highlights / 01 Jun 2025

Let’s be brutally honest… For most of gaming history, the phrase “Harry Potter video game” used to be prefaced by an unspoken sigh. It reminded us of movie tie-ins rushed out to meet a deadline, gameplay as sticky as treacle, and graphics that. Well, let’s just say they haven’t all aged like fine elven wine… But something shifted. Hogwarts Legacy dropped, didn’t just not suck, but became an enormous success instead. So, how did we progress from the PS1 Hagrid’s classic blockiness days to a game that finally felt like the Hogwarts letter we had all been fantasizing about? And more urgently what does this mean for the sequel already occupying prime real estate in our daydreams??

The Early Days: Mania, Memes, and “Polite” Magic

Wind your VCRs (or, you know, YouTube playlists) back to the early 2000s. Harry Potter mania was on, and with every blockbuster film came the inevitable video game tie-in. Regardless of whether you were a PlayStation devotee, a Nintendo generation, or a PC stalwart, chances are you came across these early forays into digital magic. Remember Sorcerer’s Stone? The tastefully nauseous camera angles, the relentless amassing of Bertie Bott’s Every Flavour Beans, the magic that was more of a polite request than an instruction. And, of course, the ageless PS1 Hagrid. That low-poly behemoth, an emblem of early 3D inelegance, who somehow transcended his visual shortcomings to become an internet meme. These games were naturally of their time – often janky, occasionally infuriating, but also, to some, that initial interactive hit of a world they adored. There was a charm to their genuine, if often clumsy, attempts to capture the magic.

Growing Ambitions: Towards a Hogwarts Life Simulator

As console generations went on, so did ambition (and, generally, budget) for these games. The PS2/Xbox/GameCube era treated us to games like Prisoner of Azkaban that came with lovely little added touches like the ability to play as Ron and Hermione with their unique abilities. But for others, the “Hogwarts life simulator” experience really began to come together with Order of the Phoenix and Half-Blood Prince. The recreation of Hogwarts in these games felt much bigger and more comprehensive… you might well spend hours exploring familiar corridors; discovering hidden away places to hide, and playing delightfully detailed mini-games like dueling or potion-making. Spellcasting very often employed more advanced controls, like analogue stick gestures, and introduced a much-welcome depth of immersion. They weren’t completely fetch quest- and gameplay roadblock-free, but they were a marked improvement.

Beloved Detours: LEGO Charm and Quidditch Dreams

And no Harry Potter game retrospective would be complete without a loud round of applause for Traveller’s Tales and their LEGO Harry Potter series. Across the board on every console, these games were, and remain, an absolute delight. The old LEGO sense of humour, the fun destructibility, the wonderful co-op play – they took all the best aspects of the source material and boiled them down into a version that was enjoyable and constantly rewarding for all ages. Still a great way to play through the entire saga. And who’d forget the standalone Quidditch World Cup – a game that, if not the deepest sports simulation, at least permitted us to indulge our daydreams of soaring through the air, Quaffle clutched in one hand, dodging Bludgers with (presumably) cat-like quickness. Simple, tuneful fun.

The Strange Side-Track: When Wands Became Guns

Then there was… a rather strange side-track. The Deathly Hallows games, seemingly to keep up with the darker, action-oriented tone of the final films, took the radical step of changing genres. Harry Potter was a third-person cover shooter!! Wands had become magical guns, and gameplay tended to involve taking cover behind wreckage to exchange rounds of Stupefy. It was a bold, if nonsensical, shift that left most players distant from the central fantasy of enchantment & magic.

The Interlude: A Longing for More

For a time thereafter, the landscape for large, ambitious Harry Potter console and PC games felt somewhat thin. Mobile games maintained the flame, but that large, open-world RPG so many had fantasized about seemed to remain firmly in the realm of fan fiction.

The Seismic Shift: Hogwarts Legacy Arrives

Until February 2023. The launch of Hogwarts Legacy came across as more seismic than game launch. Avalanche & Warner Bros. didn’t just create a game; they delivered on a promise from decades ago. Set in the 1890s, it sidestepped the storytelling complexities of the main series quickly and allowed players to create their own student and live their own tailor-made journey. The raw size and splendor of the world were breathtaking – from the painstakingly researched common rooms of Hogwarts to the expansive, untamed Scottish Highlands. Broomstick flight was exhilarating, the combat system (albeit perhaps slightly button-mashy for some players) made casting spells feel dynamic & energetic, and the basic fantasy of studying spells, attending school & unraveling ancient mysteries was rendered to breathtaking perfection.

Imperfect Perfection: Relief and Record Sales

It wasn’t flawless -> the gearing system was unoriginal, and certain of the open-world content felt faintly generic… But the general impression was one of relief and happiness. It shifted over 22 million copies, a testament not just to the enduring power of the IP, but to the pent-up demand for a really immersive, high-quality Wizarding World experience.

The Inevitable Sequel: Whispers and Gringotts Ink

Which brings us, as it must, to the whispers and speculation of Hogwarts Legacy 2. No official announcement has yet been made in a horn of owls and Ministry decrees, but the ink is on the Gringotts vault door. Games that achieve this level of commercial & critical acclaim do not receive the pat on the back and retirement to memory. Industry pundits are abuzz, job ads are under the microscope, and in all honesty, it would be business madness not to create a sequel. The hype already is an actual entity, a shared desire by millions of gamers starving for more.

The Wishlist: What We Want Next

So what do we, hardened gamers who’ve witnessed it all, want from a sequel? More comprehensive RPG systems are a necessity. Choices that hold actual weight & consequences; deciding not just cutscene bits, but the overall path of the story. An enhanced morality system that goes into the dark places of magic. And yes, by the saints, fully realized, playable Quidditch. Not a mini-game, not a cutscene, but the real deal. More meaningful conversation with supporting characters, perhaps with branching storylines and more robust relationship systems, would also be on the wishlist. Hogwarts Legacy provided such a great foundation; the potential for building upon it is enormous.

A Journey’s Evolution: From Blockiness to Breathtaking Vistas

The Harry Potter video game series has been a long and often tumultuous one -> a complex tapestry woven from strands of affectionate nostalgia, maddening limitations, and moments of outright genius. From the endearing blockiness of PS1 Hagrid to the sweeping vistas of Hogwarts Legacy, it reflects the evolution of gaming itself. Hogwarts Legacy felt like a destination many thought we’d never reach… and now, the prospect of a sequel isn’t just exciting – it feels like the natural, thrilling next chapter in a story we’re all eager to continue playing…

Join the Debate: Your Memories and Must-Haves

What are your top Harry Potter gaming memories – the good, the bad, and the side-splittingly janky? Was PS1 Hagrid a living legend in your living room? And what must-have features simply have to be included in Hogwarts Legacy 2 for it to be the greatest magical odyssey ever? Let us know in the comments below – let the great wizarding debate begin!

Falagar

He is the founder and editor of Magic Game World. He loved gaming from the moment he got a PlayStation 1 with Gran Turismo on his 7th birthday.
View all posts